Call Us
May 26, 2026

Why Are So Many People Leaving the Church?

Joshua Tufte

A Giant question facing the next generation of the church

Lately, it feels impossible to ignore that people are leaving churches. Some quietly disappear, some leave angry, some slowly drift away, and some walk away from Christianity altogether. Honestly, there are also many people who still love Jesus deeply, but aren’t sure they want anything to do with church anymore.


I think for a lot of Christians, that reality feels heartbreaking. But if we’re being honest, it also makes sense. A lot of people leaving the church are not leaving because they hate God. Many of them are exhausted, hurt, disappointed, burned out, or simply tired of trying to sort through all the noise surrounding modern Christianity.


The hard truth is that the church has earned at least some of the criticism it receives. Not all of it, but definitely some of it. People have watched pastors fall publicly. They’ve seen manipulation, hypocrisy, power struggles, celebrity culture, politics replacing Jesus, and churches that cared more about protecting reputations than protecting people. After enough of that, people naturally begin asking, “If this is Christianity, do I even want it?” And honestly, that’s a fair question.


Because many people are not rejecting Jesus. They’re rejecting distorted versions of Him.

We also can’t ignore the fact that people constantly see terrible examples of church leadership online and in headlines. Every few months, there seems to be another story about pastors stealing money, affairs and scandals, manipulative leadership, fake spiritual healings, emotional pressure tactics, scams disguised as faith, or churches using people instead of loving them. And honestly, it’s disgusting—not just because it hurts people, but because it damages the witness of the Church as a whole.


What frustrates me sometimes is that this is the complete opposite of what most churches actually look like. Most churches are filled with ordinary people trying to follow Jesus the best they can. Most pastors are not trying to become celebrities. They’re counseling marriages late at night, praying with grieving families, working long hours, trying to keep ministries afloat, helping people through addiction, loss, depression, and crisis, while also trying to shepherd people through their own humanity.

But those stories rarely make headlines. Faithfulness usually doesn’t trend. Scandal does.


And when healthy churches do share good things happening, there’s often another criticism waiting. People assume they just want attention, are trying to look good, or are only serving publicly for applause. That creates a strange tension because if churches stay quiet, nobody sees the good being done, but if they share stories, some people immediately assume it’s performative.


Still, I genuinely believe most healthy churches are not trying to build celebrity. They’re just trying to help people.


And despite all the failures, I still deeply believe in the Church. Not because churches are perfect, but because Jesus still loves His Church.


I’ve personally seen churches help save marriages, feed families, support foster care and adoptions, show up after disasters, walk with people through grief, help people recover from addiction, visit hospitals, counsel people through depression, and help lonely people find community. Most of that happens quietly.


In fact, churches and faith-based organizations are among the largest sources of volunteer work and charitable outreach in the country. Millions of volunteer hours every year come directly from local churches. Faith-based adoption and foster care organizations have helped place hundreds of thousands of children into homes, and churches mobilize massive disaster relief efforts after hurricanes, floods, fires, and tornadoes. Long after media attention disappears, churches are often still there serving meals, cleaning debris, housing families, and helping people rebuild their lives.

That matters.


Healthy churches quietly become part of the backbone of communities, and honestly, I think a lot of people don’t realize how much communities would miss if healthy churches disappeared.

Now, with all that said, I also understand why finding a church can feel difficult right now, especially when it seems like so many people are leaving them.

So how do you even find a healthy one?


My advice is simple: slow down and research before jumping in. Watch a few sermons online. Listen carefully to what they actually teach. Pay attention to how they talk about people. Look at what they do for their community. See if their actions match their message. Look for authenticity, not perfection.

Personally, I would encourage people to stop choosing churches primarily for convenience. Don’t just choose the closest church, the coolest building, the best production, or the most entertaining communicator. Look for honesty, humility, biblical teaching, healthy leadership, real community, genuine service, and people who openly follow Christ.


No church is ever going to be perfect, but healthy churches should consistently point people toward Jesus instead of toward themselves.


Honestly, I think one of the biggest reasons people are leaving churches is that people are starving for something real. Not polished branding, performance, or celebrity Christianity. They want real people, real worship, real repentance, real grace, real community, and the real Jesus.

And honestly, I think that’s where hope is.


Because while some churches are dying, others are becoming healthier than ever—not because they’re trendy, but because they’re authentic.


And if you’ve been hurt by the church, I genuinely am sorry. Truly. But don’t confuse broken people with a broken Savior. Jesus is still good even when Christians fail to represent Him well.


And maybe the future of the Church won’t be built by people pretending to have everything together. Maybe it will be built by honest people who know they desperately need Jesus, too.

share this

Related Articles

Related Articles

By Joshua Tufte May 26, 2026
What does God really say about intimacy? Explore a healthy, biblical perspective on sex, design, and building strong, faithful foundations for marriage.
By Joshua Tufte May 22, 2026
I thought everyone knew...
When you mess up blog image
By Joshua Tufte April 15, 2026
Mortification is a massive part of leadership. Whether your leadership role is in your home, your workplace, or beyond, people are watching. And as Christians, we are often under a level of scrutiny that feels heavy and constant. How do we walk through fires in life? How do we deal with frustration, lose our tempers, face addictions, shortcomings, and failures? The scenarios are endless, moments where others are watching. And whether we want to admit it or not, they are looking to us to see who Jesus Christ is… or at least to watch us fail. So the question isn’t whether or not we are leading someone. The real question is: what are we leading them toward, and is it worthwhile? And even when we choose to pick up that mantle, that responsibility, we still mess up. Sometimes in very public ways. Sometimes in ways that leave us mortified at our own actions. Sometimes accidental. Sometimes intentional. Sometimes deeply hurtful, until we stop and realize the damage that’s been done. For me personally, I’m no stranger to embarrassment. In many cases, it’s not intentional failure; it’s things that slip through the cracks. Missed appointments. Texts that go unanswered for weeks because they slipped my mind. But then there are the bigger failures, the ones everyone else gets to see. Being a pastor is a lot like living in a fishbowl. And when there’s something wrong in the water, everyone notices, and everyone has something to say about it. I’ve grieved my sister’s loss in front of hundreds of people. I walked through a divorce while pastoring a church of several hundred people and was well-known in the community. I’ve been stopped in Walmart and told how evil I was, because, of course, it happened at Walmart. From that, and too many other situations to list- I’ve learned a few things. 1. Thick Skin Is Not Optional If you are going to put yourself out there and lead in any capacity, someone will have a problem with you. Most likely, multiple people will. And often, they will be people who don’t fully understand what’s actually going on—but know just enough to say something that stings. If I’m honest, that’s frustrating. Because sometimes these are people who contribute nothing to your life, yet their words still hurt. And that can make you even more upset. So you have to learn to prioritize who you listen to and who you work for. Pick five people. Five voices that truly matter. Make sure they are mature, close to you, and trustworthy. Don’t give this privilege to just anyone. Choose people who know you, who love you, and who are willing to speak truth into your life. Then remember who you are ultimately leading for: Christ first, Family second, Friends and those who don’t know Christ next. When you align who you listen to and who you’re doing this for, the hard days don’t necessarily get easier, but they do gain purpose. 2. Approval Is a Trap You Can’t Win Working for the approval of others while leading is a battle you will never win. It’s incredibly easy to fall into the trap of doing what you do because it feels good to be needed… and praised. I’ll be honest, there’s real joy and fulfillment in providing value to others. There’s something deeply satisfying about helping people, leading well, and seeing impact. But that can’t be your driving force. Because there will always come a moment when you do something people don’t like, and they will leave. Often loudly. Sometimes angrily. Take joy, even healthy pride, in leading and serving well. But don’t let feedback define you. Christ should define you. At the end of the day, when my life is over, I want to stand before Jesus and, God willing, hear, “Well done, good and faithful servant.” That hope drives me. It gives me purpose. It pushes me forward. And yes, there are people who believe that will never be said about me. Some with reasons. Some without knowing the full story. But that’s okay. They are not my audience. Jesus Christ is. And when that perspective shifts, everything changes. 3. Bravery Is Not Optional Whether your leadership role is parenting, pastoring, or leading in a boardroom, you will fail publicly at some point. Why? Because leadership requires risk. And risk is necessary. Pushing limits is good, and stepping out in faith is essential. But sometimes, it will go badly. It takes real bravery to take those risks, knowing you might fail, and to choose to do it anyway. One of the best ways to build that bravery is to remember your wins. Not to inflate your ego, but to remind yourself that failure isn’t the full story. Final Thought Time heals more than we think. What feels like a massive, overwhelming failure right now, one year from now, most people won’t even remember. So don’t give up. Don’t shrink back. Don’t let failure convince you to stop leading. Because mistakes will happen. But they don’t have to define you. They can refine you. And if you keep moving forward, God can still use every part of your story, even the parts you wish never happened.
ALL ARTICLES