August 19, 2025
Biggest Mental Health Myths In Church (Destroyed)
Joshua Tufte
Biggest Mental Health Myths in Church
When the Church Gets It Wrong: Confronting Mental Health Myths
For a complete list of sources, see the References
section at the end of this post.
Sadly, the church can sometimes mirror culture by veering toward extremes. On one end, we dismiss mental‑health struggles as a lack of faith or prayer. Ed Stetzer
warns that some leaders assume mental illness is caused by spiritual deficiency, leading to spiritual abuse when sufferers are told to “just pray it away.” Steve Austin
shares that in his evangelical congregation, if you couldn’t “shake off” depression, you were told you weren’t praying enough; he even hid his medication because he feared judgment. Research shows that most pastors rarely talk about mental health, and many congregations have no plans to help families affected by it. In this environment, medication and counseling can be viewed with suspicion or outright hostility.
On the other side, some in our culture glorify
mental illness, treating it as an identity badge.
Neither extreme helps.
The truth lies somewhere in between: mental‑health challenges are real and complex, but they’re not a sign of weak faith. The brain is an organ like any other; factors such as nutrition, exercise, and sleep
affect its health. Competent therapy and appropriate medication can be gifts from God. Trusting God doesn’t rule out doctors or medicine. Prayer, worship, and Bible study remain invaluable, but they’re enhanced—not negated—by counseling, medication, healthy eating, and rest. As the church, we must acknowledge mental illness without glorifying it, encourage spiritual practices without dismissing medical ones, and offer compassion and support to those who struggle.
Myth 1 – “Christians shouldn’t struggle with mental health.”
Truth: You can love Jesus and still battle anxiety, depression, trauma, or burnout. God cares about your mind and is committed to your wholeness.
Elijah’s story shatters this myth. After defeating the prophets of Baal (1 Kings 18), he ran for his life when Jezebel threatened him. Exhausted, frightened, and discouraged, he begged God to take his life (1 Kings 19:4). God didn’t rebuke him or tell him to “just pray more.” Instead, He met Elijah in his depression with compassion: an angel brought him food and water, then let him sleep. Later, God spoke not in earthquakes or fire but in a gentle whisper
(1 Kings 19:11‑13), reminding Elijah that He was still with him in the quiet moments of despair. Elijah’s experience shows that even faithful heroes can face mental‑health lows—and God doesn’t shame us for it. He meets us there and restores us.
Verses to remember:
1 Thessalonians 5:23‑24, Isaiah 26:3, Psalm 42:11, 1 Kings 19:4‑8.
Myth 2 – “Anxiety means you don’t trust God.”
Truth: Anxiety is a signal, not a sin. It invites you to bring your worries to God and trust Him to carry them.
One of the godliest people I know—someone whose life radiates grace—has fought depression for years. His love for Jesus is unmistakable: he prays faithfully, studies Scripture deeply, and lives out his faith in acts of service. Yet his struggle with anxiety and depression hasn’t gone away. Rather than undermining his faith, it’s refined it. His prayers are more honest, his empathy deeper, and his dependence on God more evident. He clings to passages like Philippians 4:6‑7—casting his anxiety on Christ and receiving a peace that surpasses understanding—and 1 Peter 5:7, trusting that God cares for him. Instead of viewing depression as a sign of spiritual failure, Let’s see it as a place where Christ meets us and continues to shape our lives.
His testimony is a living rebuttal to this myth, showing that genuine faith can flourish through mental‑health struggles.
Verses to remember:
Philippians 4:6‑7, 1 Peter 5:7, 2 Chronicles 20:3‑12, Psalm 55:22.
Myth 3 – “Depression means there’s something wrong with your faith.”
Truth: Depression doesn’t disqualify you from God’s love. Your feelings are valid but not permanent; God’s compassion is new every morning.
This myth often springs from a well‑intentioned but ultimately misleading message: “If you just live right, pray more, and trust God, everything will be perfect.” Scripture never says that. Sometimes we sell Jesus like a quick fix or an escape from all troubles. Well‑meaning pastors or friends might promise that Jesus will make every problem disappear. But when depression, anxiety, or hardship inevitably arise, believers can feel confused, ashamed, or abandoned—thinking their faith must be deficient.
The Bible never promises an absence of suffering. Jesus Himself said, “In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world” (John 16:33). Following Him doesn’t shield us from pain; it means we never face pain alone. God did not
promise days without pain or laughter without sorrow; He promised strength for the day and comfort in our tears. Isaiah 41:10 reminds us that God is with us and will uphold us, while 2 Corinthians 1:3‑4 calls Him “the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort.” So the idea that “if I do everything right, my mental health will be perfect” isn’t just unrealistic—it’s unbiblical. Faith doesn’t guarantee smooth sailing; it guarantees a faithful Captain in the storm.
Verses to remember:
Lamentations 3:21‑23, Psalm 34:18, Romans 8:38‑39, 1 Samuel 1:10.
Myth 4 – “If you worry, you lack faith.”
Truth: Jesus acknowledged our tendency to worry and offered a better way: trust your heavenly Father. Worry reveals where we need to grow, not how much faith we have.
We often equate faith with flawless certainty—believing without doubts or anxieties. That misunderstanding leads some to condemn any hint of worry as evidence of weak faith or divine displeasure. Yet Scripture and experience show the opposite. Emotions aren’t switches we flip on and off; they’re part of how God made us. Fr. Jim Van Vurst addresses this concern head‑on: it is not a sign of weak faith when we worry. True faith is rooted not in our shifting feelings but in a heart that chooses to trust God. Even Jesus, facing the cross, prayed in agony and fear. To pray and trust in God while feeling afraid or worried is, in fact, **a sign of great faith.**
Everyone worries about something—that doesn’t make us faithless; it makes us human. The key is how we respond. Instead of letting anxiety drive us to despair, we can see worry as an invitation to lean harder on Christ. The Bible repeatedly calls us to cast our cares on Him (Psalm 55:22; 1 Peter 5:7) and to trust God with all our heart (Proverbs 3:5‑6). Jesus invites, “Come to me, all you who are struggling hard and carrying heavy loads, and I will give you rest.” Author Alicia Bruxvoort notes that when we bring our burdens to Jesus, He lightens our load. Sometimes that looks like daily rhythms of prayer, reciting Scripture to shift our focus, or simply admitting our needs. Worry doesn’t dismiss faith; it can deepen it.
Verses to remember:
Matthew 6:25‑34, Luke 12:22‑31, Psalm 46:10, Philippians 4:8.
Myth 5 – “Your thoughts control you.”
Truth: Thoughts are powerful, but they aren’t the boss of you. The Holy Spirit empowers you to renew your mind and take every thought captive.
Our minds can feel like runaway trains—unwelcome thoughts appear out of nowhere, and it often feels like we’re passengers rather than drivers. This myth feeds the lie that we are powerless against our thought patterns. In reality, Scripture and research affirm that we can redirect our thoughts.
Your life moves in the direction of your strongest thoughts.
Left unchecked, consistent thoughts become actions, actions become habits, and habits shape our character. That’s why Paul calls us to “take every thought captive… to make it obedient to Christ.”
Taking thoughts captive isn’t passive. It requires consistent, intentional direction and a steady diet of truth. A devotional on spiritual input uses the “garbage in, garbage out” concept from computer science to illustrate this. If we allow garbage to fill our hearts and minds, we reap anger, envy, and other destructive behaviors. But if we let God dwell in our hearts, follow His word, seek His help in prayer, and surround ourselves with Christ‑like people, our attitudes begin to display the fruit of the Spirit. Paul echoes this when he urges us to think about whatever is true, noble, right, pure, lovely, and praiseworthy.
Practically, that means feeding your mind with Scripture, prayer, and worship. Colossians 3:2, Philippians 4:8, and Romans 12:2 remind us to set our minds on things above and be transformed by renewing our minds. When we dwell on God’s truth—through daily reading, meditating on verses, singing worship songs—we gradually replace unhealthy thought loops with life‑giving ones. When negativity pops up, we can counter it with a verse or a prayer. Over time, the input of God’s Word and the practice of prayer and worship reshape our thought patterns. Our lives truly will move in the direction of our strongest thoughts—so let’s anchor those thoughts in God’s goodness.
Verses to remember:
Romans 8:5‑6, 2 Corinthians 10:5, Philippians 4:8, Psalm 103:1‑5.
Myth 6 – “Trauma means you’re broken beyond repair.”
Truth: Trauma leaves scars, but it doesn’t define you—God does.
Genesis teaches that humanity was created in God’s image and likeness. That identity isn’t erased by abuse, betrayal, or bad choices. **You are not defined by your past, your heredity, or your environment; you are a beloved child of God**. Jesus even reframed a man’s lifelong blindness as an opportunity “that the works of God might be displayed” (John 9:3). God doesn’t just call you—He qualifies you. One article notes that God “rarely calls the qualified but qualifies the called,” promising to equip us with everything needed to do His will. Our mistakes, failures, and traumas don’t disqualify us from His service; they often become the very places where God reveals His grace. The gospel offers sustaining hope and healing, teaching that our identity is **not in our past but in Christ who has redeemed us**. The Bible acknowledges trauma yet refuses to let it define us.
Redemption also means God forgives completely. In several New Testament passages, the Greek verb *aphiēmi* (“forgive”) is in the perfect tense, indicating a past action with ongoing results. When Jesus says your sins are forgiven, it isn’t just for the past—it’s a once‑for‑all act that covers past, present, and future sins. Our failures no longer define us because God has decisively removed them.
Finally, trauma can be a place of divine purpose. Paul wrote that intense affliction taught him “to rely not on ourselves but on God” and that his suffering produced “an eternal weight of glory”. The same article reminds us that our trauma doesn’t save us; Jesus does. God doesn’t cause abuse or tragedy, but He can redeem our wounds by using what we’ve learned to comfort others (2 Corinthians 1:3‑4).
Your scars can become a source of compassion and testimony that furthers His kingdom.
Trauma is real, but it isn’t your identity. God assigns your worth at creation, seals it through redemption, and continues to forgive and heal. Your story—even its painful chapters—can be part of a larger story of grace.
Verses to remember:
2 Corinthians 1:3‑4, Romans 8:28, Isaiah 61:1‑3, Psalm 147:3.
Myth 7 – “Burnout means failure—you just need to try harder.”
Truth: Burnout is a warning light, not a badge of shame.
It’s easy to think we’re failing when exhaustion hits. Experts emphasise that burnout is not a personal weakness but a reaction to chronic, unresolved stress. Psychologist Britt Slief puts it plainly: “Burnout is not a sign of weakness, but a warning signal from both body and mind that fundamental change is needed”. Treating burnout as laziness ignores the alarm our bodies are sounding.
From my perspective, burnout rarely stems from having “too many things on our plate.” It occurs when we don’t complete enough tasks and don’t leave margin for rest. Unfinished work keeps our minds spinning, and a schedule packed too tightly wears us down. Research‑backed advice mirrors this: establishing routines, prioritising tasks, and breaking them into smaller steps can reduce overwhelm and increase satisfaction as you progress. Regular breaks and self‑care—sleep, exercise, mindfulness, joyful activities—replenish mental energy.
Rest looks different for each person. For some, it’s a long run or a workout; for others, it’s reading a novel, spending time with family, gardening, or even playing video games. Whatever replenishes your mind and soul can be an act of worship and self‑care. Intentionally finish what’s necessary, say “no” to what isn’t, and carve out margin for true rest. Then burnout becomes what it was meant to be—a warning light leading you toward healthier rhythms rather than an indictment of your strength.
Verses to remember:
1 Kings 19:3‑12, Matthew 11:28‑30, Psalm 127:2, Mark 6:31.
Summary
Mental‑health challenges are rising, but they’re not a failure of faith. As a church, we must resist both romanticizing
mental illness and dismissing
it. We honor God when we embrace spiritual practices and the common graces of counseling, medicine, healthy habits, good sleep, and supportive community. Christ calls us to walk in truth, compassion, and hope—bringing our whole selves, including our minds, before Him.
With Love,
Josh Tufte
References ↴
1. churchandmentalhealth.com
2. vox.com
3. gotquestions.org
4. leeanngtaylor.com
5. proverbs31.org
6. stanthony.org
7. wohbm.org
8. humbleddaily.com
9. thebiblespeakstoyou.com
10. biblicalcounseling.com
11. greekwordstudies.blogspot.com
12. kidscentralinc.org
13. speexx.com
14. openup.com
share this
Related Articles
Related Articles
How Do We Fix Anything? In a world full of war, politics, injustice, inequality, and beyond, how do we fix anything? Over the years, as a pastor, I’ve heard this question asked numerous times in various ways. It usually boils down to a deep sense that we can’t really affect anything. The world’s problems are overwhelming, and they always will be. With the advent of social media and global news at our fingertips, and every other media outlet constantly forcing headlines down our throats, it’s easy to feel helpless. How do we do anything about it? Eventually, many people land in a place of inevitability. The world is going to hell in a handbasket, and there’s nothing we can do about it. That mentality leads us to blame others, develop a defeatist outlook, become jaded and negative, and ultimately lose sight of what is actually important. One of the more recent conversations I had about this was with a very sharp, very driven young man in our church. He genuinely wanted to help. He wanted to make the world a better place. But he didn’t know where to start or how to make a difference. He had recently taken on a leadership role in his neighborhood and was already discouraged by the resistance he was facing. He worked hard, applied creativity to solving problems, and kept running into wall after wall. I’ve heard story after story like this. And over time, I’ve come to believe that generally speaking, people do want to help. They just don’t know how, and eventually they feel defeated. So the question becomes: Why worry about other people’s problems at all, right? While that mentality is understandable, it can lead us into some dangerous places as a society. It can also lead us somewhere very different than what Jesus talked about. Throughout both the Old and New Testaments, God’s Word repeatedly reminds us that true religion includes caring for the vulnerable, widows, orphans, and those in need. “Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress…” — James 1:27 “Defend the weak and the fatherless; uphold the cause of the poor and the oppressed.” — Psalm 82:3 So how do we care without becoming overwhelmed? Over the years, I’ve developed a simple framework that has helped me tremendously. These are three questions I ask when deciding where to focus my energy. First: Is this important to my family and me? Second: Does this affect my immediate community? Third: Is there anything I can actually do about it? If the answer is no to two out of those three questions , I leave it alone. Often, I add it to my prayer list, which is powerful, but beyond that, I let it go. Many times, that means intentionally avoiding conversations, news cycles, arguments, and debates surrounding it. This allows me to focus on what is important , immediate, and doable , while giving to God the things I cannot control. Let me give you an example. Currently, the U.S. military has commenced major operations in Iran. Reactions to this have been wildly different depending on political alliances, media outlets, and personal perspectives. Is that important? Absolutely. Does it affect my immediate community, my church, my family, my business, or my town, in a way I can directly influence? Not really. Can I fix it? Not even close. And honestly, I’m not even sure I would want to. Decisions like that involve layers of information, intelligence, and strategy that most of us simply don’t have access to. So what can I do? I add our troops and our country to my prayer list, and I move on. That may sound harsh, but here’s the reality: You and I only have so much influence and so much capacity. That capacity looks different for everyone, but one thing we all share is that both our influence and our capacity are limited. If I spend all my energy worrying about things I can’t directly affect, then I’ll miss the thousands of people I can affect who are right in front of me. By serving in the church, engaging personally in the community, exerting social influence, praying, and building everyday relationships, I can focus my attention where it can actually make a difference. And when we do that, we become far more effective. Does this mean we don’t care about war or larger global issues? Not at all. Those things should affect us deeply. The loss of life is heartbreaking and tragic. And lives will be lost. That should absolutely weigh on our hearts. But we cannot allow ourselves to drown under the weight of the entire world’s problems. God, and only God, has the capacity to carry the sins of the world on His shoulders. We are not Him. In fact, at its core, believing we can or need to fix everything can become somewhat egotistical. Scripture reminds us clearly of the limits of our role: “Be still, and know that I am God.” — Psalm 46:10 God calls us to be faithful where we are, with what we have, among the people He has placed around us. When we focus there, on what is important, immediate, and doable, we can actually begin to change the world around us. And sometimes, that’s exactly how God changes the world.
Grace and Truth… which one actually matters more? I think this question might be at the root of a lot of the tension and disunity we’re seeing among Christians right now—especially in how we respond to the culture around us. And I think some of it comes down to misunderstanding how grace and truth are supposed to work together. Hear me out. All throughout Scripture, we see two big themes in how God interacts with people: grace and truth. Even in the garden, this shows up. It was pure grace that God created us in His image and wanted a relationship with us. But there was also truth—His law. And when that law was broken, separation followed. Grace and truth, together. When Jesus shows up, He doesn’t throw out the law. He fulfills it. He teaches Scripture with wisdom that leaves people stunned. And yet… He eats with sinners. He walks patiently with imperfect disciples. He washes the feet of the man who would betray Him. That tension is everywhere. Grace and truth. Fast forward to today, and it feels like we keep picking one side or the other. Some people go all in on truth. Call everything out. Shout it down. Cancel it. If culture violates God’s design, it needs to be exposed loudly and publicly. Truth matters, period. Others swing the opposite way. “Just love people.” “Don’t worry about sin.” “Jesus forgives, so none of this really matters.” Grace becomes the whole message. The problem is… both of those miss something important. Truth by itself doesn’t save people who don’t believe. Scripture even warns us about this. Jesus talks about not throwing pearls before pigs—not as an insult, but as a way of saying you can’t expect people who don’t share your worldview to value Scripture the way you do. Why are we surprised when sinners act like sinners? Truth is mainly for the family of God. We hold Christians accountable to live like Christians. When we try to force biblical standards on people who don’t believe, it usually just pushes them further away. But grace without truth isn’t love either. Jesus didn’t come with one or the other. He came full of both. As Craig Groeschel puts it: “Truth without grace leads to hell. Grace without truth doesn’t exist.” If we judge anyone—including ourselves—by the law alone, we’re all done. Romans makes that pretty clear. None of us measure up. Not one. At the same time, agreeing with everything someone does just to keep the peace isn’t loving. If my one-year-old reaches for a hot stove, I don’t say, “Go for it, that’s your truth.” I stop her and tell her the truth—because I love her. So maybe the better question is: what if we started with grace? What if we led with love, patience, and relationship—and then spoke truth inside that relationship? Not as a weapon, but because we actually care. And if someone still chooses a path we believe is harmful, we don’t abandon them. We keep loving them. Because grace saves. Our fight isn’t against people. Scripture says it’s against unseen forces. And yet we often end up hating the very people we’re called to reach—over politics, music, or a halftime show no one will remember in a year. Is that really worth losing the chance to share the gospel? Nothing is worth souls. Jesus told us to go and make disciples, not win arguments. The people who vote differently, live differently, love differently, or believe differently are still God’s children. Yes, truth matters—but grace has to lead. Grace and truth. Not one. Both. So what does this look like in real life? It looks like this: we keep loving them. We keep praying for them. We keep showing up. We keep building the relationship. And we keep gently, faithfully leading them toward Christ—slowly, lovingly, with grace and truth working together. Jesus was perfect—the most right person to ever walk the earth. And yet sinners didn’t run from Him. They flocked to Him. Why? Because He embodied the perfect balance of grace and truth. He didn’t water down truth, and He didn’t weaponize it either. He showed us the mark to aim for. Living that way is hard. It will draw fire from both sides. You’ll be “too soft” for some and “too rigid” for others. But it’s worth it. I’ve had the privilege of walking with people who came from very dark places and watching them find salvation in Jesus Christ—seeing lives saved, changed, healed, and restored. There is nothing like it. And that only happens when we love people long enough, patiently enough, and faithfully enough to walk with them toward truth instead of trying to shout them into it. So I’d genuinely love to hear your thoughts. Where do we draw lines? How do we actually live this out day to day? Do you even agree with this? Please be kind to one another. We’re here to talk, learn, and sharpen—not fight.
Passion Family, Over the last few weeks in The Playbook series, we haven’t just been talking about vision — we’ve been talking about formation . About who God is shaping us to be as His people in this season. At Passion Church, we believe the Kingdom of God moves forward through partnership, not pressure. Through people who say, “God, You can count on me.” That’s why we’re stepping into Commitment Sunday and a Month of Partnership together. Below you’ll find links to our website with more information about Commitment Sunday, what it means to partner with Passion Church, how to get involved, and a deeper look at Project OIKOS. Please take time to read through this and follow the links. We are prayerfully inviting our church family to seek what God is calling them to do. Our next steps are significant, and this is where you can begin partnering with us. What does it mean to partner with Passion Church? On Commitment Sunday, we’re inviting our church family to prayerfully step into four commitments — not as boxes to check, but as a way of life: GROW Choosing to go deeper in your walk with Jesus — being rooted in Him, authentic before Him, and intentional about spiritual growth. SERVE Using your gifts to love people well — stepping into compassion, meeting real needs, and helping carry the mission of the church forward. GIVE Living generously — not out of guilt or obligation, but as an act of worship and a reflection of God’s heart in a broken and divided world. ATTEND Showing up consistently — building your life around worship, community, and the work God is doing through this house. This isn’t about perfection. It’s about faithfulness . It’s about alignment. It’s about saying yes to what God is doing here. A Word to Those Already Partnered With Passion Church If you are already partnered with Passion Church, I want to say thank you . Your faithfulness, generosity, and willingness to show up have helped shape this church into what it is today. Because of your commitment, lives are being changed and the Kingdom of God is moving forward through this house. During this season, we’re inviting our existing partners to renew their partnerships —not because anything was lacking, but because God is leading us into a new chapter. Renewal is a way of saying, “God, I’m still in. I’m still aligned. And I’m ready for what You’re doing next.” This season is an opportunity to recommit with fresh faith, fresh vision, and a renewed sense of purpose as we move boldly into the future together. Commitment Sunday & the Month of Partnership Commitment Sunday is the starting point — and our largest moment — where we commit together as a church family. Through this Sunday, it will not only unite us in purpose but also allow leadership, myself, staff members, the advisors, and our external oversight team (Elders) to gauge where we are in the process of launching our new campus, both with volunteers and finances. It launches a full Month of Partnership throughout February, giving everyone the opportunity to take their next step in partnership with Passion Church. Beginning February 1 and continuing through the end of the month : Partnership and commitment forms will be available at the Connection Desk each Sunday Online commitment forms will remain open on our website Upfront gifts for Project OIKOS can be given at any time Long-term giving commitments can be submitted throughout the month While Commitment Sunday is our primary push — the moment we believe God will unite us most powerfully — we also want to create space for those who are traveling, sick, new to Passion Church, or simply need more time to pray. Our prayer is that this month will align our hearts, unify our faith, and allow us to move boldly into our next season together . Learn More About Partnership Here Project OIKOS Out of this posture of partnership, we are stepping into Project OIKOS. OIKOS is a biblical word meaning household, family, and those entrusted to our care. Project OIKOS is about building a spiritual home — a place where people can belong, grow, heal, and encounter Jesus for generations to come. Our overall goal is to raise $285,000 over the next 24 months . As part of that, we are prayerfully asking God to provide $120,000 in upfront gifts by the end of April , leaving $165,000 to be fulfilled through long-term giving commitments over the remaining 24 months. I want to say this clearly and pastorally: Project OIKOS is not about money first. It’s about mission. It’s about stewardship. It’s about obedience. Giving is simply one way we participate in what God is doing — alongside growing, serving, and showing up. Learn More About Project OIKOS Here How to Make a Commitment If you’re able to be with us in person on Commitment Sunday, we would love for you to participate together as a church family. If you can’t be there in person, you can still partner with us. Our Commitment Sunday page on the website will be live starting today, and you’ll be able to submit your commitment online. Additionally, commitment cards will be available at the Connection Desk throughout February for anyone who wants to commit in person after Commitment Sunday. Throughout this series, we’ve been reminded that: God is generous, and He forms generous people The world is divided, and the Church must look different Love becomes visible through sacrifice When God’s people commit together, God moves powerfully So here’s my pastoral invitation to you: Pray. Seek the Lord. Talk as a family. Ask not, “What’s expected?” but “What is God inviting us into?” And whether you are partnering for the first time or renewing your partnership , this Month of Partnership is your opportunity to say yes. We are not trying to build something flashy or glamorous. We are building something faithful. Something rooted. Something that will impact lives for generations. I am honored to walk into this next season with you. With gratitude and excitement, Pastor Josh Passion Church